That's a little extreme. I agree, that is a very poor analogy, and IMO, inappropriate. Yes, I believe something precipitated it. Please note that I also said the sucker-punch was bush. Yes, I think that these MANAGEMENT-participants (especially Perry) need to be severly punished. If Duncan did anything other than try to stop any violence, yes, he should be suspended as well. I did not say that Duncan started it, but that SOMETHING precipitated it? What that was I don't know. But yes, I believe that something precipitated the punch. Doesn't justify it, but it does explain it. I know what it says in the article(s), but I do not believe that everything makes it to the newspaper. There seems to me to be some bad blood between LaRussa/Duncan, and a number of other team's staff. Now, I NEVER said it was all anybody's fault in particular, but most certainly, I believe that there is likely enough responsibility to go around to all parties involved. I most certainly am biased. I am a Cub fan, and as such never claimed to be unbiased. However, I simply posed some questions about the situation.