No, that's not what i'm saying. In the terms we're talking about, smart = good. He may fail, but in terms of expected performance out of a GM going forward, I'd take the smart guy every time. That doesn't mean he is incapable of failure. It means I think his chances of failure going forward are less than that of others. You are ignoring the fact that Theo is no longer one of only a few smart guys in baseball, or the smartest.