We aren't talking about guys with well rounded skillsets. We are talking about one dimensional players whose dimension isn't nearly as important as the one they don't have. For the sake of arguement, if these were rounded skillet guys, that type of thing tends to work out better when you already have Manny, Papi, Damon, Drew, and Pedro. Yeah, forget for a moment that half (or more) of the guys rob listed were and/or are very good hitters, they had a solid lineup top to bottom. You can fit in the cheap defender when you already score lots of runs.