To be fair, they had great matches at 2007 Wimbledon and 2009 Aussie Open as well and Federer and Roddick had the epic at this year's Wimbledon. This was my favorite of those, 30 games in the final set. Longest final in Grand Slam history, longest since 1927, career Grand Slam record being broken. I didn't think the 2008 final could have been topped but they did it.