This probably better goes in the DH/NL thread, but mostly the same reasons other people don't (strategy, baseball is 9v9, not 9v9.5 or 9v10, not letting AL pitchers throw at batters with relative impunity because they don't have to hold the bat, etc). In general, I get tired of leagues changing rules to appeal to the masses (looking at you, NBA) rather than just playing the game. I saw a graph the other day, intended to strengthen the case for the DH, that showed pitcher wRC+ has steadily declined since the DH was enacted. Gee, I wonder why that is. As is the case with seemingly everything in sports (changing the PAT, allowing basketball teams to move the ball to half-court without taking up time as if they stepped through a time warp, JumboTrons), I am resigned to the fact that I am going to be outvoted. except baseball is 9.5v9.5 or whatever you want to call it in 50% of the major leagues and the majority of others And I don't like it there, either.