Wow? I didn't ignore the age of the players, because the age of Cedeno and Theriot is insignificant - unless the Cubs are banking on either one of the two guys to being the SS of their future. So, why should the Cubs suffer through having Cedeno learn "on the job?" Sure he has plenty of talent, but mentally he is not a mature player - as you can tell if you note his baserunning miscues, his mental errors defensively, and his mindless approach at the plate. I'd love for Cedeno to pull it all together and take the SS job, but until that happens Theriot is best option on the Cubs roster. It's not a "man crush" or hate for Cedeno. Because you don't lose anything, Theriot is already the baseline of performance. If Cedeno fails, then he's Theriot. Perfect way of putting it. Hell, even in Cedeno's TERRIBLE 2006, the difference in OPS was only .610 to Theriot's .672 of 2007. I wouldn't quite go to that level. 62 points is a pretty dramatic difference. If you added 62 points to Theriot's total, you'd be getting close to Cedeno's upside for this year, wouldn't you? I can't see him suddenly figuring out major league pitching and becoming an .800 OPS SS, at least right away. Plus his 2006 included some terrible defense from Cedeno, and also an 8 out of 16 SB ratio (Theriot's 28 out of 32 SB's does add value, although not as much as the people who think he should be a starter think it does). Those have to be factored in. So Cedeno's ceiling is much higher than Theriot's, and his floor is also lower than Theriot's. The Cubs need offense enough to warrant giving Cedeno another chance to gamble on his upside, but it definitely is a gamble and I don't believe for a second that Cedeno at his worst is Theriot. Take out Theriot's 1 huge month and does that change anything? I frankly don't think Theriot's 2007, as bad as it was, is his floor. You could say the same thing about Cedeno's April 2006 month where he had a .815 OPS, which happened to be the only month that season where he was above .665. Cedeno's floor could definitely be below his 2006 numbers, especially since he had 4 straight months where he he had OPS numbers of .599, .605, .467, and .465 while playing everyday. Except that was 2 years ago, not last year - Theriot was horrible last year. Cedeno was really good in AAA last year, really good (from what I hear) in winter ball right now, and he's at an age where you would reasonably expect improvement. So telling me his terrible age-23 season is his floor 2 years later isn't really reasonable.