I'm skeptical. I do not like what Soriano brings to the table, and he doesn't get on base enough for me. I hope Lou finds his balls and banishes him to be the best 5-7 hitter in the MLB. Getting on base is only part of the equation. In the bigger picture, scoring runs is the most important stat in baseball, because runs win games, hits and walks do not. Last year, Soriano led the team in runs scored and he only played in 135 games. He drove himself in 33 times via the home run. He had 45 doubles and 5 triples. Theriot, Fontenot or Reed Johnson will not provide that kind of production, so why let those guys step to the plate more often than Soriano? If Theriot, Fontenot or Johnson could provide a really good OBP, then I might join the battle to move Soriano down in the order. But, they aren't assured to have an OBP any better than what Soriano provides, therefore it makes much more sense to bat Soriano at the top and allow his bat more opportunities to manufacture runs. I would also argue that if you had better hitters hitting in the 6-8 in the line up, which the Cubs can very easily do with the current roster, Soriano would have a shot at 100 RBI as a lead off hitter. He had 95 in Washington as mostly a lead off hitter with a whole bunch of really crappy hitting teammates. Technically, he scored 102 runs in 131 games and he drove in 81 as a lead off hitter that year. Soriano fits the mold much like Curtis Granderson and Jimmy Rollins. Neither of those guys put up stellar OBP's, but the XBH power generates a lot of runs. Guys who can generate runs with such ease should be occupying line up spots that give them as many opportunities as possible. Period.