Yes, there are numbers that support Soriano for lead of argument. RUNS SCORED. Soriano scored 97 runs last year in only 135 games. Think about that for a minute. He was flailing away at pitches last year. He failed to work counts last year and he was whiffing with the best of them last year. He was on pace to score more than 110 runs batting lead off for the Cubs last year even though he was flailing and whiffing a lot. It's what he does when he does make contact that makes all the difference. I'll be the first to admit that it's very frustrating to watch him when he's struggling. But, he was also on pace to hit nearly 100 XBH's last year, which is what makes the guy valuable. I'd love it if he was more selective at the plate, struck out less and stopped swinging at bad pitches. If he did that, he probably would be the best hitter on the team and hitting 3rd or 4th would make the most sense for him. But, no matter how you attempt to spin that he isn't productive in the lead off spot, Soriano's past records indicate that he is very productive in the lead off spot, both in scoring runs and driving in runs. Theriot, on the other hand, played in more games than Soriano, hit at the top of the order nearly as often as Soriano, and only scored 80 runs and only drove in 45 runs. This is not the type of guy you want hitting at the top of the order. So far, he hasn't hurt the team too much hitting 1st or 2nd as much as he has. But, when he slumps, he'll be very detrimental to the most important stat in the game of baseball. CROSSING THE PLATE. I'm sure you get frustrated watching Soriano flail at everything. I do to. But, he's here and he'll be here for a long time, so we might as well get used to it. But, let's at least stop ignoring the production he brings once his bat starts making more contact.