Nobody is telling you they never try to, what they are saying is that in the end, the theory that 1s face 1s all the time is absolutely bogus. No matter how hard you try, you can't do it. The schedule makes it impossible. Managers might try and matchup against a certain rival that way, but even then, they'll be lucky just to be able to get their 1 vs a top 3 guy, let alone the actual #1. Furthermore, team's real #1s often times aren't labeled #1 because baseball people are slow to pick up on change. I never said that they try to do it all the time. The fact is, Brandon Webb will face guys like Peavy and Schmidt more than anyone else in their rotation. I'm not saying it is a huge factor, but it is a factor.