i need to know more about the home run guy. we know what the first guy is doing every time up, getting on first base. But we only know something about one of the PAs from the home run guy. In his other ABs, is he simply doing something other than hitting home runs - whether it be hit a double, walk, strike out, ground out, etc.? Or is he an automatic out for every other PA in the game? If he's even having a Neifi result in his other ABs, it makes it a tougher choice because at least Neifi will get on base a quarter of the time, so you add that to the HR and you've got a very productive player. But if he's hitting one HR per game and then making an out every other PA, I'd definitely take the 1.000 OBP guy.