If you had let one go... (Walker or Nomar)....

[Balsa]

Which one would you rather lose?

 

http://static.flickr.com/26/56565436_e1223498f6.jpg

Edited October 27, 2005 by Balsa

[Schwarber Fan]

captain injury

[Andy]

The one that looks like a Mafioso in the pic above.

 

But seriously, Walker is cheaper and a consistently healthy .300 hitter who can take a walk. Keep him.

[Marco4]

Early indications point one way.

[jkrapfl]

I didn't know we had the option of trading Nomar.

[Balsa]

I didn't know we had the option of trading Nomar.

 

LOL

 

Touche.

[CaliforniaRaisin]

Depends on who I'd get as a replacement - but I'd prefer keeping Walker since he's on the cheap.

[sethuel1]

The one that looks like a Mafioso in the pic above.

 

But seriously, Walker is cheaper and a consistently healthy .300 hitter who can take a walk. Keep him.

...but it's a soft .300

[Andy]

The one that looks like a Mafioso in the pic above.

 

But seriously, Walker is cheaper and a consistently healthy .300 hitter who can take a walk. Keep him.

...but it's a soft .300

All the more reason why he should have been batting 2nd or even 1st this year as opposed to 6th which is where he ended up. Our manager is an idiot.

[CuseCubFan69]

It really depends on what the Cubs do. If they resign Walker and get an impact player for him and resign Nomar I'm for Walker going. But, if the Cubs sign Furcal or make a deal for another SS that can hit and play good defense I would like Walker to stay. Let me add if it's between Nomar and Perez then Nomar by a long shot and Walker ha to go.

[frostwyrm]

Nomar is a failed experiment and I don't see him as an everday SS anymore. He needs to move to 3B permanently, and if he lands on a team with a lefty 1B he could make himself more useful by learning 1B too.

[barrettismyidol]

Sorry Nomar.

[TC3_Hinrich12]

The one that looks like a Mafioso in the pic above.

 

But seriously, Walker is cheaper and a consistently healthy .300 hitter who can take a walk. Keep him.

 

Walker is a 32 year old who is also injury prone and cannot field... at all. Cheap or not, in my opinion, he has to go. They both have to go.

[Balsa]

Well I think Hendry has made his choice, and it happens to coincide with this poll....maybe he saw my thread?

[TC3_Hinrich12]

Well I think Hendry has made his choice, and it happens to coincide with this poll....maybe he saw my thread?

 

Not necissarily (butchered that), he could be looking to trade him.