College Football - Week 12 (Nov. 18)

[NewUserName]

I think Michigan's real beef with the refs should be theses Pi

[PackLandVA]

UMfan

 

There was no overturned TD in the Michigan game. The call on field was out of bounds, no TD. And there was nothing at all on the replay that clearly showed one foot was down before the othe was out of bounds that would allow refs to overturn call on field.

 

That said, I have no idea how earlier in the game, replay overturned a catch for a first down by a Wisconsin receiver. Scratched my head on that one.

 

Both teams have great Ds, but the Michigan offense is way more inept than Wisconsin.

[UMFan83]

UMfan

 

There was no overturned TD in the Michigan game. The call on field was out of bounds, no TD. And there was nothing at all on the replay that clearly showed one foot was down before the othe was out of bounds that would allow refs to overturn call on field.

 

That said, I have no idea how earlier in the game, replay overturned a catch for a first down by a Wisconsin receiver. Scratched my head on that one.

 

Both teams have great Ds, but the Michigan offense is way more inept than Wisconsin.

 

This is a great study in fan bias (for both of us). You are right they called it incomplete on the field. They shouldn’t have. My eye and the (admittedly biased) screencaps shown on twitter suggest that his foot landed inbounds first. The overturned catch could have gone either way but the ball hit the ground and when it did it looked to me like the ball moved ever so slightly which I believe means no catch.

 

Both very close plays that I don’t think either of us will be able to convince the other to change their mind about.

[PackLandVA]

The difference in our “biases” is that I don’t think there was enough to overturn either call. Yet one call was overturned and the other wasn’t.

 

And you’re correct, neither is us will sway the other from our opinion. The non-TD in my opinion was near impossible to see which foot clearly hit first in slomo, so how is it a BS call in the realt tme if the ref sees it as out of bounds?!?

 

Anyway, Michigan has an awful offense and that’s their downfall this year.

[OleMissCub]

Wow

 

[Derwood]

Maybe in the future the NCAA should explain the new rules to the referees some time before the season starts

[Andy]

This ND crapfest is the least surprising thing ever.

[Derwood]

I don't think Nebraska is going to win this one

[Ding Dong Johnson]

I’m shocked at the number of people I know who are shocked Iowa lost again. I can’t wait for the next generation of Ferentz ball

[CaliforniaRaisin]

UCLA and Jim Mora don't deserve Josh Rosen.