They're just about equals in my book right now. What advantages Murton has offensively are balanced by the advantages Cedeno brings defensively. Murton gets a higher rating when talking about the lineup. He's the better hitter. When thinking about the order, Murton gets a higher billing. When talking about overall value as a player though, the position comes into play, and Cedeno gets a bounce there. Neither player is likely to be great, for his position or otherwise. Both should be perfectly acceptable for their position, age and cost, though. I think the second Cedeno struggles he'll be on the bench learning how to hit from Perez. Cedeno, if he gets to struggle and battle his way out of a slump, will hit 260/310 and since Baker is the manager IMO he will see that and put the gold glover Perez in instead. I think he'll be a decent SS but will he actually be good enough to put up better numbers than Perez? Is a 290/300-340/350 really in his future and what SS's is he equivalent too? I really don't see him as fast but he seems to have a good arm and range.