Well, let's look at the Yankees system. They traded away most of their minor league talent for higher-priced stars, leaving them with a $200 million budget and no exceptional talent pool to draw from. And as we can see, $200 million does not guarantee a WS. For the Cubs to trade away the majority of their farm only to buy them back in free agency leaves the team at a financial disadvantage and potentially gets back guys who have already hit or passed their prime. The Cubs are doing a good job of trading prospects for quality players. Especially in this market, I'd be more apt to continue their SOP than to sell the farm. Your argument is hurt by the fact that the Yankees won 4 WS in 5 years using the philosophy your describe. If that philosophy netted the Cubs just 1 title, I'd be for it. The philosophy the Yankees used to win those titles was based upon building from within. Jeter, Williams, Rivera, Pettitte & the real core of that team all came from the farm. They added role players through trades & FA (such as O'Neill & Tino), but didn't go after the huge stars. When they started shelling out the huge dollars is when they stopped winning titles. Posada as well correct? The Yanks seem to go in cycles... before they won they seemed to buy old guys and had no real farm system (the Mattingly era) then after enough losing Steinbrenner left the team alone and they built their farm system up that produced all of their players up the middle. And they won. Now Steinbrenner is getting his hands dirty and screwing things up again and they should get worse before better.