According to baseball savant, 38 players have at least 10 opportunities at a 5 star catch this year. Everyone besides PCA have made 21 5 star catches combined and no players have made more than 3. PCA has 10 by himself. And it’s not like he’s had way more chances either. He’s one of 8 with 15+ chances. He’s made 10 of 15, which is a 66.7% success rate. Second place is Eli White at 33% and he’s 1-3 this year.
For his career he’s 18-32, which is a 56.3% catch rate. There’s only 1 player who has a 30+% catch rate who has more than 8 chances, which is Andrew Toles at 4-13 (30.8%). PCA’s 18 catches is also tied for the most with Kiermaier and Michael Taylor. Those two have 102 and 148 chances at 5 star catches.