Eyre wasn't good, and he was terrible for his contract. Erye was great before his injury in August. He got progressively worse as the season went along. April/May: 27 IP, 1.18 WHIP June/July: 21 IP, 1.38 WHIP Aug/Sept: 13.1 IP, 2.25 WHIP And you can't say that he performed admirably for his contract and then try to excuse poor performance due to injury. His performance is what it is. Even if you're saying he should improve because he was hurt, then it takes me back to the point that he's 35 next year, and the weight/conditioning/injury concerns aren't going to go away, and his quotes on the matter don't inspire much confidence of him improving upon it