He had a 139 OPS+ in Arlington, it's not like he was hitting the same as everyone else in that park. His overall OPS+ is nearly Top 5 in the AL. He's 4th in the AL in Runs Created, 5th in Win Shares and VORP, 8th in EqA, 2nd in Equivalent Runs, and had a 9.4 WARP3. EDIT: I can only assume you're referring to the Awards voting thread, in which a whopping total of 8 people voted and placed Hamilton an average of 7th in AL MVP, and no higher than 4th.