I have no problem with Hawkins, my problem was always with how Baker used him. He had proven he couldn't close, and he wasn't signed to be a closer. Hawkins' problems closing games in 2004 was a function of Baker's bad managing. When I think of the bad contracts Hendry gave to relievers, I think of Eyre and Howry, though they didn't really go bad until their third years. But that just serves to illustrate the risk in giving more than a year or two to relievers. Hawkins was never really terrible (or even bad, statistically), and he was gone after a year and a half.