This is all because of the AL East problem and it's making the rest of baseball suffer. The season is 162 games long. We don't need any more games to decide who should get a chance at the WS. Here are some scenarios that are not far-fetched and will likely happen at least once in the next five years: 1. WC #1 beats WC#2 by at least 4 games in the 162 game season, but loses a 1 (or 3) game playoff and misses the playoffs. Therefore, September was basically meaningless for WC#1. 2. The two best teams in one league are in the same division. They have to play a tie-breaker game because there is no way that you can just give the division to one team and force the other to go to the play-in game. So, the two teams with 95+ wins are playing each other before the playoffs start. Then, the loser has to go and play a do-or-die game (or games) before being allowed to go on the road (if they win) in a best-of-5 series against a team that has a worse record than them and was able to rest for at least two extra days to line up their rotation. Meanwhile, the winner of the divisional tie-breaker had to use one of their starters (possibly their ace) to get to the playoffs against a team that had a worse record and did not have to use their ace pitcher. We all know how important pitching matchups are in a best-of-5. In general tie-breaking scenarios become ridiculous. What happens when three teams tie for the wild card or the division? In 2007, the Padres, DBacks, and Rockies came within one game of tying for the best record in MLB. The Phillies, Mets, Padres, DBacks, and Rockies were all within 2 games of each other, with 3 of those teams at 89 wins, one at 88, and one at 90. If the Mets had just beat the DBacks one more time, they would have all been tied. What would MLB do if they all tied? The 5 best teams in the league get to slug it out for a week while the Cubs sit on the sideline and watch? I'm sure there are more scenarios out there. These are off the top of my head. There are way too many issues to be ironed out here, and almost all of the solutions involve the best teams getting screwed. Most likely we will see automatic tie-breakers at the end of a 162-game season. No thank you.