A complicating factor is that I believe Al's move was actually made AFTER you said teams no longer participating can't pick up players, while Adam's move was BEFORE. What I think is the fairest solution for this year is to allow the moves, but open up a reasonable window (maybe two weeks) if anybody else wants to pick up any minor league eligible players (not including 2010 draftees), with the caveat that they need to keep their minor league roster legal at the maximum of 10. Everybody would thus have the same opportunity. Going forward, I suggest modifying the rules to clearly state that, once teams are no longer participating, they can't pick up any players. Teams still participating I think should be allowed to pick up an injury replacement if needed with the understanding that the player must then be dropped after the team is no longer participating in the playoffs (as Brian did with Olivo); that way a playoff team would be able to be competitive in the playoffs without having an unfair advantage for the next year. So my actual vote in the Roadkill poll will be to allow the moves, but with the qualification I stated in this post.