I don't think so. When I hear the GREAT and FEARED players of this league, Chase Utley is rarely mentioned. Utley is a DAMN good player, but like Derek Jeter, he's slightly overpaid, due to the "GRIT" factor. I said, slightly overpaid, he's more of a $10-12 mill per, and not $13 mill +. I'm talking about the Chase Utley that right now looks like he could have a better career than Jeff Kent and Ryne Sandberg. Which one are you talking about? http://www.baseball-reference.com/friv/scomp.cgi?I=utleych01:Chase+Utley&st=career How about the one, who career's numbers are in line with Bill Hall ($4.8 mill this yr), Victor Martinez ($4.25 mill this yr), David Wright ($5 mill this yr) and Jose Reyes ($4 mill this yr) and Grady Sizemore ($3mill this yr)? Thes guys are in his same group (25-30 yrs old). And while they don't play the same position, it doesn't change the facts his numbers are no different then said players. So, while Utley is a damn good player, I don't view him as highly as some. So yeah, I would not pay Utley more then $12 mill per yr. Is that simple. Utley has been overrated, just a tad. Not Jeter'd, not even Theriot'd, but slightly overrated. And I wouldn't say he would a better career then Sandberg and Kent, I would say he would be on par with both guys. In that bandbox of a park, I could see him pass both guys, but Kent and Sandberg were more important to their teams in their heydays (Cubs and Giants), then Utley is to the Phillies.