great idea. right off the top of my head, i'd have to say it's between hill and cedeno. hill is 10-4 with 185 k's in 122 2/3 ip...era in the mid 3's. plus, when evaluating him against guys like pinto, you have to consider the fact that he jumped from AA to the big leagues this year while pinto is repeating AA. and i'm aware of the fact that hill was too old for AA when he started there, but now he's back on the proper age path. also, cedeno, in my opinion, has clearly had a better season than murton, who i'm sure a lot of people will vote for. same obp, higher avg, higher slg. plus he plays a position where his numbers are well above average, while murton plays a position where his numbers perhaps slightly above average.