He was an obvious pick, not a good one. Teixeira was the pick they should have made that year. Hands down, no questions asked. If he was drafted as a 1B, I couldn't disagree with you more. If there was a thought he could stick at 3B or in the OF, I might agree with that. Top flight arms are so hard to find (and keep healthy) that when you have an opportunity like Prior, with his perfect mechanics and great stuff, I just don't think you can chance passing it up. You can build a solid offense without a super elite bat, but it's tough to win big without that TOR arm. They don't stay healthy, he didn't have perfect mechanics. If you could guarantee they'd both have full careers you take the pitcher. But that guarantee doesn't exist. You take the pitcher, I'll take the bat, and you will lose most of the time I will win most of the time and that is all that matters in baseball.