Boring people like to be bored. Or baseball is a game based on a pitching STAFF, so some people would like more than one game. I understand why people like the one game. I understand why people like the three game series. I understand why people don't even want the second wild card. There is no correct way of doing it just differing opinions. Baseball is not a game based on a pitching staff. You're joking, right? I'm not discounting that some people think non-decisive games are boring. What percentage of them do? I don't know. Not every stance you take has to be debated so that you win the argument. When you try to win every debate instead of discussing them you say things like, "Baseball is not a game based on a pitching staff." I am not joking. Baseball is not a game based on a pitching STAFF. You just made that up. Baseball is a game based on 9 innings, during which each team has 3 outs to try and score runs. The success of any major league baseball team over the course of a full season is largely dependent on its pitching staff, but not entirely. And the importance of that staff is diminished significantly in any short series. You count on your pitching staff, and your entire roster, to get you into position to compete in the playoffs. If you are good enough, you win your division. If you aren't good enough to win your division, you hope for an opportunity with the wild card. This system opens up that opportunity to more teams, which means more fan bases have more reason to pay attention late in the season and care. And it rewards both winning your division, and being the 1 seed.