I hold out some hope that he can catch in the future but I believe it is pretty crazy to think he can do a good job catching now, with such limited coach and experience at the pro level and having such a long road to go down even if the experiment does succeed. If the good habits are not already second nature to him, then starting him 80% of the time starting now is a terrific way to have him go back to bad habits that are more comfortable and natural to him. There is no ongoing instruction if he's catching practically every day. He's playing 9 innings each game at AAA now. I'm not sure I follow why him catching as frequently at the MLB level is going to cause him to revert to bad habits, or that he can't be coached while playing full games just like he was at Iowa. Like any other player, the results do not matter at AAA but they do in the majors. The problem with catcher is it is nothing like the 7 other positions when it comes to learning to do it properly. You can ad lib in LF and even a middle infielder can presumably just do what comes naturally. The pressure to do what he is more comfortable doing while maintaining the responsibility of catching a major league staff nearly every day is completely different than continuing to learn the ins and outs of catching in Iowa. Any error, misplayed ball or poorly framed pitch has the potential to be magnified a million times what it would in AAA. Couple that with game planning and calling games for this staff and it is completely understandable why management would not want the kid as their everyday catcher. Unless you do not think there is actual value in learning how to catch in the minor leagues you have to see the drawbacks of throwing him out there 5-6 times a week. Plus, you are ignoring Ross's bad brain and the lack of any good players being held down unfairly because of this move.