Different situations. Our ceiling next year is a borderline playoff team - whether we got Dunn or not. The next year would be our best shot to have a good Dunn and a good team. After that, the possibility gets much higher that we have two bad contracts hindering our upside as we should be a very competitive team. With Gonzalez, he should be very good to great for the first 2-3 years of the contract at least - which lines up right with when this roster should begin moving upward rapidly. Also, I'm not terrified of paying Dunn at 33-34 years old. I can understand why you would want him and he definitely makes us better, I just don't see the reward being higher than the risk that he tanks for a year or two. Terrified? That's kind of crazy. The guy has patience and power. Those things tend to last. He may struggled in his mid-30's, but if you are terrified of paying Dunn at 34 you have to be terrified of paying pretty much any free agent in baseball. Exactly. I wouldn't say terrified as I wanted Dunn. I just want Gonzalez more, that 4th year is not so much a detramint on Dunn as it more so adds more value towards getting Gonzalez instead. If we get no one then avoiding Dunn was a huge mistake. That being said Dunn playing for the White Sox makes more sense for him personally than playing for the Cubs. If we matched the contract there is nothing to suggest that he would still choose the Cubs over the White Sox.