Luck, and it's not even close. Luck is the #1 pick if he comes out. He has all the makings to be a Tom Brady or Matt Ryan type QB. He won't wow you with off the chart arm strength and measurables, but he is the best leader, most poised, and most cerebral QB that I have personally seen since Peyton Manning. And he has the ability to make every throw. Luck may not even come out though. You don't think he'll come out? I kind of assumed he would. I tend to think Mallett's more of a boom or bust guy. He could be better than Luck, but is also probably more likely to flame out than Luck. After Mallett and Locker, what QBs likely to be in this class do you really like? I should know more off the top of my head, but I don't. Luck in heartbeat just because he is a smarter and more athletic QB. Personally I like Luck more than Bradford. For whatever reason when I see Mallett I think of Cutler. I do like Mallett a lot too. I think the only reason Luck may not come out is because of a potential holdout. Snead and Locker have given him too many reasons not to comeout.