Agree to disagree. I think a high-ceiling guy like Caissie has more value to this organization than a guy like Cam Smith, who has a higher floor. And Cam Smith was the main piece returning an MVP candidate. Alcantara is controlled, but currently has nowhere near the value of Kyle Tucker.
This is really just personal preference. Alcantara for Alcantara, that I can live with. Add Birdsell or another non-Wiggins arm of their choosing and a low-level lotto ticket.