First time, he was coming off TJS and a 6+ ERA. The second time, he would be coming off a league leading ERA among starters and on a team with a lack of starting pitching. The point isn't even whether or not there would be significant consequences. If you want to turn your organization into one of the premier franchises, it's probably not best to act like a petulant child. he said the cubs should do what's best for them and he'll do what's best for him. If the cubs think giving younger guys some starts on a dead-end team is the best thing for the team, Dempster can't do crap about getting put in the pen. The union would have no leg to stand on either. "Hey, I turned down a trade to a contender after originally telling the FO that I'd accept a deal to that team and b/c of that, the FO couldn't get decent value for me, so they put me in the bullpen and now I'm less valuable. Can you, um do something?"