And that goes back to what SSR said, I'm not sure I really buy defensive metrics for a 1B. Nor do I think they matter a ton, especially in comparison to pretty much every other defensive position on the field. And as long as he's not running into outs stupidly on the bases, is that really costing you that much? A lost run is a lost run, doesn't matter what position it's at. At least, as I understand the metric. Right, but in a situation where that one run really matters (at least late in games), you pinch run for him and mitigate some of that problem. Admittedly, him not scoring from 2nd on a single in the 4th inning could cost you a game, but again, he fills such a huge hole that I'm willing to deal with the downside to get the big bat in the lineup. He's certainly a flawed player, but when a guy has an OPS/OPS+ like he does every year, that's just kind of a risk you're either willing or not willing to take.