That was a very good game against a poor defense and in 46 attempts, but it was still just one game. He's also had playoff games where he's missed 60% completion and even 50% completion. He's a game manager who won't do anything particularly well except avoid mistakes (since 2011, prior to that he was a mistake machine). The problem is, you don't have to pay a guy $10+ per year to achieve that. Any way you slice it pretty much, he's now being paid like a top 10 QB and, like you said, he's nothing more than an above average starter and that's with an elite running game (gotta question how long Charles will keep this up). It's not some terrible, crippling contract, but there are better ways to spend that money than to lock up a QB who's really nothing special. Anybody equivalent or better is going to cost as much or more and if you take a guy in the draft, you're pretty much eliminated the win now mode they're in. I don't see any issue making that move whatsoever.