When looking at a player most people use their 3 year averages, all I did was add this season to that. Who cares what someone did 4+ years ago? 4 years ago Sosa was a 35+ HR hitter still. One year of good stats can be a fluke so easily you want to look at more than 1, two years can still be pretty flukey especially with a guy like say Peralta who had one good and one bad year. Three years gives you a decent size sample. You guys are really stretching things to try to make your argument. How are we stretching things to say Zambrano has been a better pitcher than Sheets outside of April and May of '07? Take any year, take any 3-year split, take the whole career, coming into this year, Zambrano was better than Sheets every year aside from '04 which could be called a wash. Yes, we know, Zambrano had a lousy start to this year. Very lousy,, even so much as to push his "3.5 year splits" about even with Sheets.