More pesky stats incoming (these ones I had to figure out mostly on my own, so...) Win shares are basically a stat designed to compare across eras and positions. It's adjusted to era, but also includes fielding for hitters and pitching (for pitchers, obviously). For purposes of how good a player would be, I took the average win shares of a player with that many appearances, and took the overall difference to be Win Shares Above Average (hardball times does this, but they didn't have this data for everyone). So, cumulative WSAA for famous Cubs (except Cap Anson, because WS data isn't available prior to 1900): Player (Years as Cub) WSAA (as Cub)
----------------------------
Hartnett, Gabby (19) 132
Sandberg, Ryne (13) 103
Williams, Billy (16) 102
Chance, Frank (15) 101
Sosa, Sammy (13) 87
Santo, Ron (14) 86
Wilson, Hack (6) 69
Banks, Ernie (19) 58
Grace, Mark (13) 54
* Ramirez, Aramis (7) 33
Hornsby, Rogers (4) 32
* Lee, Derrek (6) 27
Dawson, Andre (6) 18
* Soriano, Alfonso (3) 8