nope. good hitting beats good pitching. eckstein, molina, rolen, etc were just better than pudge, guillen and granderson. prove me wrong. I'm sorry, but the Cardinals had guys playing WAY over their heads such as Eckstein and Molina and Preston Wilson. The playoffs are a small sample size. I'd still take Pudge, Polanco, Guillen, and Granderson over guys such as Molina, Eckstein, Miles, and Wilson. Abuck doesn't believe what he's saying, he's trying to show that you can't prove either argument but that some are saying good pitching beats good hitting as a fact without proof. Ok. In that case, I would say good pitching, for the most part, beats good hitting. Detroits pitchers did struggle though when it mattered most. That and creating extra outs for a team that is in the World Series usually will come back to bite you in the rear end. St. Louis' rotation pretty much sucked though, as well as most of their team. If you look at the teams that have made the World Series in the past 5 years or so, about 80% of those teams had great pitching staffs, which propelled them to the Series.