Whenever he gets moved into the middle of the order, he stops hitting homers and starts sucking. At least that's my perception. I wonder if the stats back it up. I'd bet he has a much higher home run rate with no men on base, as opposed to when there are men on base. Of course, no one here believes in "clutch" so if it's true, its probably pure coincidence. The last 3 years: 2008 Nobody on: 284 AB's, 18 HR, .885 OPS Runners on: 169 AB's, 11 HR, .860 OPS 2009 Nobody on: 311 AB's, 10 HR, .685 OPS Runners on: 166 AB's, 10 HR, .802 OPS 2010 Nobody on: 269 AB's, 10 HR, .720 OPS Runners on: 227 AB's, 14 HR, .934 OPS And so far this year (excluding tonight): 2011 Nobody on: 38 AB's, 5 HR, 1.087 OPS Runners on: 47 AB's, 2 HR, .524 OPS So perception is not reality in this case. As for the middle of the order, he only had 76 AB's total for the 3-5 spot from 2008-2010 so very little to go off of. I would say that perception is skewed by the fact that he strikes out a lot, which makes it seem like he is performing poorly with runners on base because his strikeouts are magnified.