Geez. I can't freakin stand the showboater, but the guy is a no-doubter great defender. This is like judging Randy Johnson's career by how he pitches now. Just not fair, nor reasonable. And add to it, his brain is in scrambles, and we "hate him" and think he sucks. Geez... I guess we just can't recognize the he WAS good, and enjoy the fact that he's not raking or bringing in lots of extra base hits. And while playing shallow is stupid for most, Edmonds got away with it most of his career. On the plus side, he threw out lots of potential runs by playing so shallow, and even prevented some from running on him because of that shallow depth. Most typical basehits or run-scoring shots were taken away because of that strategy. Are we just jealous that we haven't had a decent CF in so long?