This is a very, very good question. When it comes to starting pitching, I think the comparison is dead on. '04 Cards (playoffs) - Morris, Williams, Suppan, Marquis '05 Sox - Burhle, Garland, Garcia, Hernandez/Contreras The biggest difference is the #1 starter. The Sox have one, Cards didn't last postseason. Suppan was their best starter, and Woody Williams wan't too bad, either. Morris, Williams, and Marquis were all very similiar 6 IP, 4 ER + guys last fall. I don't see Garland (no track record), Garcia, El Duque or Contreras (all inconsistent), doing much different than that. If the sox add a big gun with AJ Burnett or another starter coming over, that makes the comparison void. The offenses aren't even close, and the pitching difference will be greater. If you're looking to say the '05 Sox will collapse like the '04 Cards did, which is possible if the Sox get the postseason jitters, then you'd have to expect injuries, which is really what killed the Cards season last October (Morris, Carpenter, Rolen, etc) :roll: .