Theriot looked good defensively when he got his hands on the ball. But because his arm is so weak, he was playing in a few steps, which comprimised his range considerably. All in all, he was below average with the glove, simply because he could never get to the ball. Everett shouldn't have to compete, he'd be hands-down a much better option than Theriot. Yes, he should have to compete. If he is much better than Theriot (and I think he is) it would be evident from the competition. Would it? I'm not comfortable choosing a starting player based off a few spring training games. Obviously, if Everett lost a bunch of range and it showed from April through May, we can consider going in another direction... but Theriot isn't close enough right now to warrant leaving it up to chance.