Where you bat, where you field, and how much you play should be based on performance. If that is the metric, then who would you be targeting to bat 2nd based on each player's most recent performance (2005): A. 268 ab, .280/.300/.714, 33 r, 6 bb/26 k B. 254 ab, .299/.351/.843, 36 r, 20 bb/23 k ? As for Murton, I completely agree that he's got a chance to be a superb #2 hitter, but I don't see that as being a likely scenario. I really feel like Dusty is going to slot him 6th going into the season. If I had to guess on opening day: 1. Pierre 2. Walker 3. Lee 4. Ramirez 5. Jonez 6. Murton 7. Barrett 8. Cedeno