Depends on how well you think Gallagher could do in Marshall's spot. Almost .200 OPS points is a MASSIVE improvement. We can't just look past that fact. Look, I would LOVE to have Griff and his 900 OPS in our lineup, but at what cost? If the deal were Gallagher, Petrick and EPatt I'd do it without a second thought, but I'd guess they'd want more back than that. Then again, what is the real difference between Marshall and Gallagher? I know - Marshall has a ton more ML level experience. But doesn't Gallagher project as a better pitcher overall?