I'd love 23 and 10. I'd hate his ball-hogging and tantrums. Dismiss character all you'd like. Do you still think Paxson made a mistake when he dumped J.R. Smith? I said Noah was the best fit when compared against the draft alternatives you listed. There was no one left on the draft board that fits your over-6-9-back-to-the-basket requirements except Hawes, and I'm glad Paxson avoided that nonathletic, piss-poor rebounder. No, I don't think he made a mistake at the time in trading Smith. We had enough wings at that point and had recently inked an inside presence in Wallace. In order to get Wallace we had to spin off Chandler, and in order to do so we had to take on Smith. At that point dealing him to Denver made sense. With respect to your second point, you and I are talking about two different things: you are limiting yourself to draft alternatives who you assume Pax will keep. I am asserting that we should have traded the pick, drafted a player someone else wanted in order to facilitate a trade, or added greater depth to a position of strength (2's and 3's) in order to facilitate a trade.