Fantasy Trade Question

[CardsFanInChiTown]

My league vetoed the following trade:

 

LaDainian Tomlinson for Portis and Santana Moss (Was huge but has had a drop off in the last 4 week)

 

 

Question, would you have voted against this trade? Thanks!

[imb]

yes

[wolf stansson]

Depends on what place the teams were in.

[CardsFanInChiTown]

Depends on what place the teams were in.

 

The team getting LT was in first and the other team was close to last place.

[adamb0719]

Depends on what place the teams were in.

 

The team getting LT was in first and the other team was close to last place.

 

YES

[wolf stansson]

I think it's pretty fair, but I'd still vote against it out of spit for the guy in first.

[burnt out cubbie fan]

I don't normally veto trades unless they are horribly unfair. I figure if they are stupid enough to accept the trade then they should have to live with it. This one is borderline for me. If it was a keeper league then I would definately veto it.

[Roast]

That trade is very bad. Veto.

[CardsFanInChiTown]

Thanks guys, I'm the commish for this league and the guy who was getting LT threw a hissy fit.

[NCCubFan]

I have Tomlinson on my team (I had the second pick, and the person with the first pick chose Peyton Manning). I was offered Marvin Harrison, Rudi Johnson, and a kicker for Tomlinson and Mike Vanderjagt, and I turned it down. It would take a LOT more than Portis and Moss to get me to even remotely consider trading Tomlinson.

[burnt out cubbie fan]

I have Tomlinson on my team (I had the second pick, and the person with the first pick chose Peyton Manning). I was offered Marvin Harrison, Rudi Johnson, and a kicker for Tomlinson and Mike Vanderjagt, and I turned it down. It would take a LOT more than Portis and Moss to get me to even remotely consider trading Tomlinson.

I would take the Portis trade over that one.

 

Also, someone should slap the person that took Peyton.