LOCK ME (2) Metallica vs. (15) Phish

[Derwood]

Vote for your fav. Edited July 9, 2006 by Derwood

[TruffleShuffle]

I'm not high enough to vote for Phish.

[goonys evil twin]

Tough call. I really liked Metallica when they were good, but they have been bad for a long time now. And Phish was great, for what they were. I always enjoy their music.

[Tracer Bullet]

Tough call. I really liked Metallica when they were good, but they have been bad for a long time now. And Phish was great, for what they were. I always enjoy their music.

 

I agree. I don't think Metallica is really a #2 and I don't think Phish is really a #15.

[vance_the_cubs_fan]

Mettalica is an easy vote here.

[Ding Dong Johnson]

I hate Lars.

[Derwood]

I hate Lars.

 

me too. And not because of the Napster BS. If you watch the documentary "Some Kind of Monster", Lars is an all out prick pretty much the whole time. His sympathy for James' rehab, etc. is in the negative.

[Keyris]

I only like two songs by Metallica, but unfortuanatly i don't like any songs by Phish. So Metallica it is. :(

[Mizzou]

I like both, but I own more Phish CD's. Phish it is!

[frostwyrm]

Late-80's Metallica was a great band at the top of their game, now they just suck.

[Tracer Bullet]

I only liked early Metallica, but like all Phish, especially in concert.

[cubweiser03]

Pffft Phish. Gonna have to come stronger than that to oust Metallica from this tournament.

 

And yes Metallica did rock before they turned into Selloutica. But they were so strong in the early days that they can overcome the lastest crap they put out in the early rounds of this tourney.

[PrimeTime]

Metallica's last good album.... And justice For All....

[cubweiser03]

Metallica's last good album.... And justice For All....

 

Yes but its like the US Open. When you kick so much ass it gives you 10 years of exemption. In those 10 years you can suck like David Duval but man during those years you kicked ass you are still hailed as a legend for that time.

[Derwood]

Metallica's last good album.... And justice For All....

 

Yes but its like the US Open. When you kick so much ass it gives you 10 years of exemption. In those 10 years you can suck like David Duval but man during those years you kicked ass you are still hailed as a legend for that time.

 

Thank You. And Metallica still kicks all kinds of ass live. Robert Trujillo was a great addition

[littleburr24]

Ahem, Metallica SHOULD be a #1 seed, but #2 ain't bad, they'll just be a highly seeded Dark Horse if there is such a thing. :twisted:

 

But this is your tourney Derwood, not mine.

[J.R.]

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/southfork76/unknownsourceband24tn.jpg

 

http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/southfork76/metallica01.jpghttp://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/southfork76/metallica01.jpghttp://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/southfork76/metallica01.jpg

[littleburr24]

I think this post by J.R. should be the post of the year.

 

 

If it hasn't been noticeable, Metallica is my all-time favorite band.

[Shavo]

How is this even close?

[soccer10k]

Metallica's last good album.... And justice For All....

 

Yes but its like the US Open. When you kick so much ass it gives you 10 years of exemption. In those 10 years you can suck like David Duval but man during those years you kicked ass you are still hailed as a legend for that time.

 

Thank You. And Metallica still kicks all kinds of ass live. Robert Trujillo was a great addition

 

Agreed. Trujillo is awesome onstage. Metallica is the easy vote here and will always kick serious ass.

[Jazz]

How is this even close?

 

because Mettallica isn't universally appealling enough, or hailed enough to have a landslide win.

[Productive Outs]

How is this even close?

 

because Mettallica isn't universally appealling enough, or hailed enough to have a landslide win.

 

 

100 million total albums sold. not quite the beatles, but that's pretty dang good

[Shavo]

How is this even close?

 

because Mettallica isn't universally appealling enough, or hailed enough to have a landslide win.

 

:shock:

[wolf stansson]

lol @ phish.

 

 

stinkin hippies

[Jazz]

How is this even close?

 

because Mettallica isn't universally appealling enough, or hailed enough to have a landslide win.

 

 

100 million total albums sold. not quite the beatles, but that's pretty dang good

 

20 million of which you can say succeeded more because of the success of the black album, but i wont go into those waters

 

don't get me wrong, i love mettallica from Kill Em All to The Black Album, but maybe it's there last 4 or 5 effors that have subsequently disappointed me that makes me value them less.

 

But i voted for them.