Jump to content
North Side Baseball
  • Cubs Rumors & Notes

    Could Cubs Turn To Adley Rutschman To Upgrade Catching?

    The switch-hitter could be on the move from the Orioles and bring even more offense to Chicago's lineup.

    Image courtesy of Katie Stratman-Imagn Images

    Cubs Video

     

    There are grandiose and subtle ways to upgrade positions for a contending team.

    For the Chicago Cubs, who get solid production from their catching tandem of Carson Kelly and Miguel Amaya, there could be a player who could increase that output that would be beneficial for a team already in postseason position.

    One catcher out on the market, per ESPN's Jeff Passan, is Baltimore Orioles backstop Adley Rutschman. Once the darling of the Orioles' rebuild, Rutschman hasn't been the superstar they envisioned.

    A switch-hitter, Rutschman has a career slash line of .254/.342/.414. He hit 20 and 19 homers in his second and third seasons in the majors, while drawing AL MVP votes in 2022, when he finished second in AL Rookie of the Year balloting, and 2023.

    But injuries in each of the last two seasons have slowed his production. In 90 games last year, Rutschman slashed .220/.307/.366 with nine homers and 29 RBIs. He has followed that up with a .251/.331/.433 with eight homers and 47 RBIs in 67 games this year before hitting the injured list for the third time this season Monday, this one for inflammation in his left wrist. Still, he represented the Orioles in last week's All-Star Game.

    That injury will keep him out until at least the weekend of the trade deadline, which is Aug. 3. The Orioles have struggled last year and this year and with Samuel Bassallo in the fold long term after signing an extension this year, making Rutschman not as valuable as he once was.

    Still an elite defender, Rutschman is also under club control through the 2027 season, so the Orioles won't be looking to dump him for just anything, yet it wouldn't cost the Cubs an arm and a leg (maybe just an arm) to pry him away.

     

    Follow North Side Baseball For Chicago Cubs News & Analysis

    Grade the 2026 trade deadline.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Tryptamine

    Posted

    Why do people keep trying to upgrade catcher when they're already a top 10 team there?

    image.thumb.png.580b18f70fe594df912468461dd4aa44.png

    The Cubs aren't keeping 3 catchers on the roster, are you booting Miguel Amaya and his 103 wRC+ to AAA? Actually, I think Amaya is out of options, so is he getting traded?

    • Like 1
    Rcal10

    Posted

    Stupid idea. 

    PeanutPunch33

    Posted

    This would have been a good idea going into this past off-season, when Rutschman's value was at an all-time low and Amaya was coming off of a down year.  It's not happening now.  Cubs need to focus on pitching.

    I also doubt the Orioles are selling, having won 7 of their last 8 games.  

    Outshined_One

    Posted

    The Cubs also have done a really good job of developing catchers internally, and have a really promising guy in Owen Ayers who should be ready next season.

    It's not even like there are long-term concerns at the position. They're fine.

    mk49

    Posted

    46 minutes ago, PeanutPunch33 said:

    This would have been a good idea going into this past off-season, when Rutschman's value was at an all-time low and Amaya was coming off of a down year.  It's not happening now.  Cubs need to focus on pitching.

    I also doubt the Orioles are selling, having won 7 of their last 8 games.  

    Miggy had a great season last year, until he got hurt.  He was an RBI machine, and I think his wRC+ was over 120.  If I remember correctly, his average with RISP was close to .500 with wRC+ over 200.  Knowing he was healthy again, why would the Cubs trade him in the off season?

    He's not as good this year, though he's healthy.

    Either way, trading for a catcher doesn't make sense at all.

    PeanutPunch33

    Posted

    11 minutes ago, mk49 said:

    Miggy had a great season last year, until he got hurt.  He was an RBI machine, and I think his wRC+ was over 120.  If I remember correctly, his average with RISP was close to .500 with wRC+ over 200.  Knowing he was healthy again, why would the Cubs trade him in the off season?

    He's not as good this year, though he's healthy.

    Either way, trading for a catcher doesn't make sense at all.

    Yeah, you are right.  I should have said that Miggy had an injury riddled year instead of a down year.  He's always been solid when healthy.  

    ILMindState

    Posted

    3B is the spot if we really want an offensive upgrade 

    Paul Niemiec

    Posted

    I like this idea a lot. For the right price, why not. It makes moises even more tradable. Don’t need to bring back Carson Kelly for a third year. Amaya is usually a lock to miss some time. If it doesn’t work than Owen ayers should be ready soon. 

    Tryptamine

    Posted

    17 minutes ago, Paul Niemiec said:

    I like this idea a lot. For the right price, why not. It makes moises even more tradable. Don’t need to bring back Carson Kelly for a third year. Amaya is usually a lock to miss some time. If it doesn’t work than Owen ayers should be ready soon. 

     So you're going to roster 3 catchers for the rest of the year and just hope Amaya gets hurt?

    squally1313

    Posted

    13 hours ago, Tryptamine said:

     So you're going to roster 3 catchers for the rest of the year and just hope Amaya gets hurt?

    With Ayers ready soon after that!

    lfg26

    Posted

    Owen Ayers

     



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...