I kind of agree, but think it can be opened up to anyone who made a significant impact (performance-wise) on a team for an extended period of time. Peyton Manning at Tennessee, Donovan McNabb at Syracuse, Darren McFadden at Arkansas, Herschel Walker at Georgia and Reggie Bush at USC are recent examples of what I'm talking about. Reserve them not just for the greatest players to ever play the game, but also the greatest players to ever play for their respective team/school. And one year isn't enough time to make that type of impact, in my opinion. I went with at least three years. One year is foolish imo and I hope Syracuse doesn't do this foolishness with Melo but our AD is just flash and probably would do it to get a big record crowd in the Dome. I don't have a problem with your list other than Bush if he's found to be guilty of taking cash. The Yankees are the biggest goof when it comes to this. Mattingly, come on.