I would have no problem with Castillo playing second base here next season. I think he only has one more year left on his contract. He had a nice bounce back season as a lot of intellegent baseball minds thought he might. A Baker/Fontenot platoon would be better, offensively and defensively, than Castillo. And since they are both already on the roster, why waste more money on Castillo? Defensively yea it would probably be better, but how can you say it would be better offensively? Mike Fontenot was horrible last year, and is no guarantee to improve on that, whereas Castillo has been about as consistent as you can be over the last 12 years or so. A Castillo/Baker platoon is basically guaranteed to be better offensively than Baker/Fontenot. And its not like Fontenot is some defensive whiz out there at 2nd base either. How much better? Castillo's numbers as a LH vs RHP have been all over the place, and he hasn't been particularly good for a few years now. Castillo was decent against RHP(as a LH) this past season, but was worse than Fontenot(2009) the previous two years. And Baker has been better against LHP than Castillo. Fontenot has shown at least some ability against RHP. Plus he costs WAY less than Castillo. Even if you figure 100% pay increases for both Baker and Fontenot, they would combine to make less than a third of what Castillo will get paid. Then add in that both Baker and Fontenot were much better defensively, at 2B, than Castillo this year. I'm not convinced that Castillo would be better, at best it would be a break even situation, but even if he is, would he be worth spending 3x as much at 2B. A .319 .411 line vs RH's is "just decent"? Fontenot is an unknown still at this point, he had a completely miserable year last year, and there really isnt much track record to go on with him. Hes had good minor league seasons, and shown a little promise in split time also, but he was given the job last year, and tanked. Depending on the money situation, Id bet on Castillo/Baker platoon being more productive than a Baker/Fontenot platton. In an ideal world we would just keep Bradley, but Castillo would be a pretty decent return for Bradley, in my opinion. I like Castillo/Baker in the 2 hole in front of Lee, Aram, Sori, alot more than Baker/Fontenot. Fontenot seemed completely lost last year, and no one knows if its because the book is out on him, or what.