You act like everyone is saying Hoff is the next coming of Christ. Most people are saying he's doing well in AAA right now and could probably help us in RF this year. Is he the answer to all our problems? Of course not. I would expect Hendry or whatever GM we have this offseason to go after a legit RF and maybe move Fukudome to CF. I don't see why you can't let Pie, Hoff, and Dubois complete for the LF/CF job in spring training and sign Edmonds as a cheap lefty bat off the bench. At that point you have two great backup plans, and I really see Pie and/or Hoff breaking out in the bigs next year. If DuBois or Hoffpauir are competing to be starters next year, we're going to have a serious problem. Dubois, I agree, probably should have left his name off, but why not give him the chance to compete. Pie and Hoofpauir are a different story. I really believe Pie will come through, but mostly I believe that Edmonds is a legitimate backup plan. I think September will tell us a lot about the offseason. This time last year, Soto was tearing it up in AAA, but no one really considered him a legitimate contender for a starting job until his awesomeness in September. If Hoff AND Pie don't impress this September, then I'll concede the point to you. but wait until the offseason to call insane, you might be surprised.