Forgive me for not being clear. By "cheer" i meant "laud his praises," not the literal cheering at the ballpark. It's not my style to boo players and of course when at the ballpark I'll cheer for him as I will for any other player. My point was to say: "Look, I'm not anti-Pierre. I want him to succeed, just like all Cubs players. In fact, he's seems like a tremendous guy with a wonderful work ethic. I also really enjoy watching him on the basepaths. So I'm not criticizing his play for simply the sake of doing so. And when/if he turns it around I'll be the first to admit that I was mistaken about him." ...But in the meantime, isn't it okay to point out that he's really struggling? And isn't it okay to also point out that he's struggled now since 2004? And isn't it okay to express concern that maybe...just maybe...he is and will continue to be a liability for the team? Because he is right now. His play is hurting the Cubs. We really need him to play better if we are going to survive this time without Lee, Prior, and Wood. He needs to pick it up, and pick it up fast. If he doesn't, I would have no problem with a Pie callup to take his place. If Pierre doesn't get on base more frequently, he is a liability. He simply doesn't do anything else well enough to help the team in other ways. Who else is there that isn't a liability? I would go so far as to say that JP is the 3rd best hitter on this team. If all we rate him on is his OBP we are doing him a disservice. Reaching on errors actually counts against your OBP as does FC. Personally I would rather have JP on 1st with 1 out then the pitcher on 2nd and 1 out. I am for giving him (and Jones for that matter) more credit just because both of them are seemingly behind the 8 ball on this team. They both come in with such high expectations and when they didn't come out of the gate quickly there are these 10 page long threads on them. I don't feel that its fair to them or the Hendry (who also gets the heat). April is not a make or break month. If JP still has a sub .325 OBP in July then I might not be as defensible. I know the "its still early" defense is tired and often just an excuse but at the same time, I think that new players on a team deserve some added cushion. Especially for a player that is as likable as JP