It was successful in terms of relevant and entertaining baseball for 6 1/2 months and the emergence of Shaw, Busch, PCA and Horton all proving to be valuable future contributors.
Its also a success if you consider Boyd, Keller, Carson Kelly and other relievers over performing projections but that’s not always predictive of future performance, so it’s a wash for me.
But the idea it was a failure because they traded cam smith to me is nonsense. Was 2024 a success because he was mashing in AA while the ML roster finished 83-79? If you’re a Cubs fan who lives in the current reality where we’ll never be the Dodgers than winning a playoff series is a success. They had a single postseason series win since 1945 until 2015.