Shaw will probably end up being a good big leaguer, a la Happ and Nico. But I doubt he will ever end up being a star caliber player, a guy that can carry a lineup. Which is fine, I guess, there are only so many of those guys around. And still a resounding success of a draft pick if he ends up as an every day player.
However, I just think that the Cubs need one more of those guys in the lineup, preferably as a right handed masher that can obliterate left handed pitching. And where exactly can they fit someone like that? They have guys locked into every position for the foreseeable future (assuming that they find a way to keep Tuck). I guess, they can find a better platoon for Busch but how many of those guys are out there? And does that even solve the problem? Most 1b platoons are lefties anyway. Like Rowdy Tellez. Maybe Long is an option? Idk.
All of the righties on this team are basically guys who get their value from their defense, and are marginally above average as hitters, with the exception of Seiya and maybe Amaya. And the righties on this team are not getting it done vs lefties right now. Hoerner and his 5 home runs/year will not get it done. Swanson way too inconsistent. Shaw, TBD. Happ, average at best as a right handed hitter.
The offense is amazing on paper because they destroy right handed hitting, but they look dazed and confused against lefties. They mentioned on the broadcast that they are 29th in average, 27th in slug against lefties in the last 6 weeks. That needs to change, even if it requires a massive trade.